Reverse Engineering Quotes: Rights, Then Method
Reverse engineering starts from a physical sample and produces a netlist, schematic and fabrication data. The price depends on how much can be read from the board: a two-layer board with visible traces is largely a scanning job, while a dense multilayer board requires delayering, X-ray and a good deal of inference. Confirm you hold the rights to reproduce the design before commissioning the work.
Lead times are industry ranges, not commitments. Any factory's actual date depends on its queue that week, and on what else is already scheduled.
ChinaPCB.org does not quote boards and takes no commission. This page exists so that the enquiry you send to a factory is complete the first time. Send it yourself — see how to send an RFQ.
What this quote is priced on
Five to seven variables move the number on a reverse engineering quote. They are not equally important, and only the first two are usually discussed.
- How much is readable. A two-layer board with wide traces can be photographed and traced. A six-layer board with buried vias has to be delayered, and each layer is destructive and slow.
- Deliverable level. Gerber only, Gerber plus schematic, or schematic plus BOM plus test data. Each level is a different amount of inference and a different price.
- Component identification. Marked parts can be read; unmarked or potted parts have to be characterised electrically. That is lab time, not drafting time.
- Destructive analysis. Delayering, cross-sectioning and decapsulation consume the sample. If you only have one unit, the method is constrained by that.
- Verification. A re-derived design is a hypothesis until it is built and compared against a known-good unit. Verification is a separate task and is often left out.
The parameters a factory needs
This is the set that has to be in the enquiry before a reverse engineering price means anything. The third column is why each one changes the answer, which is also the reason a quote that skips it is not really a quote.
| Parameter | What to state | Why it changes the answer |
|---|---|---|
| Physical sample condition | How many units, whether populated, and whether the board is intact or damaged | Destructive analysis consumes the sample. One unit limits the method before price is discussed. |
| Deliverable level | Gerber only, Gerber plus schematic, or schematic plus BOM and test data | Each level adds inference and lab work. A price for Gerber only is not a price for a schematic. |
| Layer count and construction | Known or suspected layer count, and whether buried or blind vias are present | Multilayer boards with buried vias require delayering. That is the largest single step in the work. |
| Rights to reproduce | The legal basis you hold: your own design, licensed, or public domain | Without it the work is legally unusable regardless of technical accuracy. This is asked before any other question. |
| Firmware scope | Whether firmware is in scope, and whether the device must behave identically | Hardware and firmware are separate legal and technical problems. Combining them changes both the price and the risk. |
| Known-good reference | A working unit to compare against, and the tests it must pass | Verification needs a reference. Without one, the output is a drawing that may or may not function. |
| Non-destructive constraint | Whether the sample must survive the process | A must-survive sample rules out delayering and cross-section, which rules out confident inner-layer reconstruction. |
| Output format and EDA tool | Gerber, netlist, schematic in a named tool, and who owns the source | The output is only useful if you can edit it. Tool choice also decides whether the supplier can hand over editable source. |
Send with the enquiry
- A physical sample, or sharp photographs of both sides if the sample cannot ship.
- The deliverable level you need, and the EDA tool the output must open in.
- Layer count if known, and whether the board has blind or buried vias.
- A statement of the rights you hold to reproduce the design.
- A known-good unit for comparison, or the tests the rebuilt board must pass.
Where it goes wrong
- Commissioning before checking rights. Technical accuracy does not cure a legal problem. The output cannot be manufactured or sold, and the fee is already spent.
- One sample sent for a destructive job. Delayering consumes the only unit. The inner layers are partially reconstructed from inference, and the errors surface at assembly.
- Gerber quoted, schematic expected. Gerber describes copper, not intent. A netlist or schematic requires reading the circuit, which is a different job.
- Output never verified against a working unit. The board is built, does not behave identically, and nobody knows which of a hundred inferences was wrong.
Comparing two reverse engineering quotes
Two prices are only comparable when the parameters above are held constant. Most of the spread buyers see comes from a difference in one of these, not from a difference in factory efficiency.
- Compare the deliverable level before the price. Gerber, schematic and BOM are three different products.
- Compare whether destructive analysis is included, and how many samples it assumes.
- Compare whether verification is in scope. It is the step that turns a hypothesis into a design.
- Compare the output format. A netlist you cannot import is a document, not a deliverable.
What this page does not tell you
This page is not legal advice. Whether you may reproduce a given board depends on the jurisdiction, the age of the design and the rights you hold, and the answer is a question for a lawyer rather than for a supplier.
Related
- Reverse engineering: the legal premise before the method
- Design quotes: producing a new design instead
- Testing quotes: proving the rebuilt board works
- Prototype fabrication: building the first verification unit
Fee structure and editorial independence are described on the about page. What we can and cannot confirm about a factory is on how we verify.