PCB Cutting Quotes: Method, Tooling and Edge
V-scoring is the cheapest and removes material from the panel edge, so it needs space in the array. Routing is more flexible and leaves a cleaner edge. Laser avoids mechanical stress and is the only option for thin or populated boards. Punching needs a hard tool per design, which rarely justifies itself below a few thousand boards.
Lead times are industry ranges, not commitments. Any factory's actual date depends on its queue that week, and on what else is already scheduled.
ChinaPCB.org does not quote boards and takes no commission. This page exists so that the enquiry you send to a factory is complete the first time. Send it yourself — see how to send an RFQ.
What this quote is priced on
Five to seven variables move the number on a cutting and profiling quote. They are not equally important, and only the first two are usually discussed.
- Separation method. V-score, route, laser and punch have different setup, different edge quality and different mechanical stress. The method is the price.
- Tooling. Punch tools and router fixtures are per design. Tooling dominates the quote at low volume and disappears into the unit price at high volume.
- Internal cut-outs. Every internal opening is a separate tool path. Narrow slots and sharp internal corners force slower feed rates and smaller tools.
- Populated or bare. Depaneling a populated board constrains the method: V-score snapping damages joints, and routing needs support and clearance.
- Edge tolerance and burr. A tight outline tolerance or a no-burr requirement adds a finishing step and inspection time.
The parameters a factory needs
This is the set that has to be in the enquiry before a cutting and profiling price means anything. The third column is why each one changes the answer, which is also the reason a quote that skips it is not really a quote.
| Parameter | What to state | Why it changes the answer |
|---|---|---|
| Array drawing with rails | The panel drawing, including rails, fiducials and the gap between boards | V-score needs rail space and a straight score line. Without the array drawing the method cannot be chosen. |
| Intended separation method | V-score, route, laser, punch, or a choice you want the supplier to make | The method is the price and the edge quality. Leaving it open means the cheapest method is used, not the right one. |
| Bare or populated boards | Whether components are already assembled when the board is separated | Populated boards rule out snapping and punching. This single fact can change the process entirely. |
| Edge clearance for handling | The clearance your conveyor, fixture or housing requires from the edge | Components near the edge limit the cutting method and the tool size, and are a common source of late redesign. |
| Outline tolerance and burr limit | Tolerance on the finished outline, and whether burrs must be removed | Tight tolerance and deburring are extra operations. They are priced, not assumed. |
| Internal cut-outs and radii | Every internal opening, with the smallest internal radius stated | A router cannot cut a sharp internal corner. A zero radius on the drawing becomes a rounded corner or a slower process. |
| Quantity and tool ownership | Order quantity, annual volume, and who owns any punch tool | Tooling amortisation decides whether punching is viable, and ownership decides whether you can move supplier. |
| Board thickness and material | Finished thickness and whether the base is FR-4, metal or flex | V-score depth is set by thickness, and metal-backed boards cut differently. Thickness also limits laser cutting. |
Send with the enquiry
- The array drawing with rails, fiducials and inter-board spacing.
- The separation method you intend, or the constraint that rules methods out.
- Whether the boards will be bare or populated at the time of separation.
- Outline tolerance, burr requirement, and every internal cut-out with its radius.
- Quantity and whether you are willing to own a punch tool.
Where it goes wrong
- V-score on a design with no rail space. The boards cannot be separated without cracking the laminate. The fix is a new array, which invalidates the fabrication tooling.
- Sharp internal corners on the drawing. A router leaves a radius equal to its tool. The part does not fit its housing and the drawing is blamed on the supplier.
- Populated boards sent for V-score. Snapping stresses joints and cracks MLCCs. The damage is intermittent and appears as field failures rather than line rejects.
- Punch tool paid for at prototype volume. The tool costs more than the boards it separates. At prototype quantity, routing or laser is almost always cheaper overall.
Comparing two cutting and profiling quotes
Two prices are only comparable when the parameters above are held constant. Most of the spread buyers see comes from a difference in one of these, not from a difference in factory efficiency.
- Compare the method. Two quotes for different methods are not competing on price, they are competing on edge quality.
- Check whether tooling is included and who owns it.
- Compare what happens at internal corners. One supplier may quote a radius you did not draw.
- Compare the burr requirement. Deburring is a separate operation that is easy to leave out of a cheap quote.
What this page does not tell you
This page does not recommend a separation method, because the choice depends on your array, your housing clearance and whether the board is populated. The constraints are described above; the decision needs your drawing.
Related
- Cutting and profiling: V-score, route, laser and punch
- Drilling quotes: the other operation that defines the board
- Metal-based quotes: where punching usually appears
- Rigid quotes: the array this operation acts on
Fee structure and editorial independence are described on the about page. What we can and cannot confirm about a factory is on how we verify.